In many organisations, Social Media Checks are already part of recruitment and safeguarding processes, particularly within regulated sectors. While many organisations acknowledge the value of understanding online risk, the way these checks are carried out is often inconsistent and informal.
In the absence of a clear policy or structured process, informal social media screening can expose organisations to compliance, fairness, and reputational risk. When checks are conducted without defined criteria or oversight, decision making becomes difficult to justify, audit, or defend, particularly in sectors where transparency and safeguarding are critical.
This article explores the risks associated with informal social media screening and explains how professional, governed Social Media Checks can support fair, consistent, and defensible recruitment practices.
What is informal social media screening?
Informal social media screening typically occurs when hiring managers, recruiters, or team members independently search for candidates online, often using personal judgement rather than agreed organisational standards. These checks are rarely documented, may vary between individuals, and are usually carried out without a formal policy or governance framework.
While often well intentioned, informal screening introduces inconsistency into the recruitment process and can undermine an organisation’s ability to demonstrate fairness and compliance if decisions are later challenged.
Why informal screening creates compliance risk
One of the primary risks of informal screening is inconsistency. Different hiring managers may view different platforms, apply different thresholds, or interpret content subjectively. This lack of standardisation makes it difficult to ensure candidates are being treated fairly and equally.
From a compliance perspective, informal checks can inadvertently expose decision makers to information that should not form part of a recruitment decision, such as protected characteristics or content taken out of context. Without clear boundaries and defined criteria, organisations may struggle to demonstrate that decisions were made objectively and in line with employment and equality legislation.
In regulated sectors, where safeguarding, accountability, and transparency are paramount, these risks are amplified.
The challenge of auditability and defensibility
Another key issue with informal screening is the absence of an audit trail. When checks are carried out informally, there is often no record of what was reviewed, when it was reviewed, or how conclusions were reached.
This lack of documentation can create significant challenges if decisions are questioned internally, through complaints, or during external audits. Organisations may find it difficult to evidence that screening was conducted fairly, proportionately, and consistently across candidates.
Supporting fair and consistent recruitment practices
When social media screening is approached thoughtfully and professionally, it can support fair recruitment rather than undermine it. A governed process helps ensure that all candidates are assessed against the same standards, reducing the risk of bias and subjective interpretation.
For organisations operating in education, healthcare, and other regulated environments, this consistency is essential to maintaining trust, safeguarding individuals, and protecting organisational reputation.
Moving from informal to informed screening
Social Media Checks are now a recognised part of modern recruitment. The key consideration for organisations is not whether checks take place, but how they are conducted.
By moving away from informal practices and adopting professional, governed Social Media Checks, organisations can bring clarity, consistency, and confidence to an area that is often misunderstood or inconsistently applied.
Final takeaway
Professional Social Media Checks play an important role in modern recruitment, not by increasing scrutiny, but by improving governance. When carried out within a clear framework, they support fair treatment of candidates, reduce compliance risk, and provide organisations with defensible, auditable processes they can stand behind.
Contact Us
Get in touch with us to learn more about our expert Social Media Checks:
Telephone: +44 333 210 1688
Email: info@sp-index.com
Join us on LinkedIn here to stay updated with the latest insights, trends, and exclusive content.
